Essay 12 Monkeys Tv

SyFy's Mediocre TV Version of “12 Monkeys” Struggles to Find Identity

by Brian Tallerico

Print PageTweet

The strength of its source material and a strong central performance by its female protagonist keep SyFy’s “12 Monkeys” from completely falling flat, but this is a show that feels like it’s constantly working against itself, overlaying too much of its dialogue with exposition, working on cheap sets, and filling out supporting roles in unengaging ways. It’s a show that disguises its inadequacies through sheer will of pacing, sending characters running, often through time, in an effort to keep viewers from getting bored. It doesn’t quite succeed. If the show can settle in, let its cast play character instead of plot, and work its themes instead of its twists, “12 Monkeys” could work. For now, I’d rather just watch the Terry Gilliam film every Friday night.


Based on that Oscar-nominated hit starring Brad Pitt, Bruce Willis, and Madeline Stowe (itself loosely based on Chris Marker’s “La Jetée”), “12 Monkeys” stars Aaron Stanford (Pyro in the second and third X-Men movies) as James Cole, the only hope for the future of mankind. At some point in the near future, a deadly virus will kill a vast majority of the human race, leaving in its wake only a select few survivors who haven’t become murderous scavengers. Visions of this desolated vision of a post-virus 2043 definitely call to mind AMC’s far-more-engaging “The Walking Dead” in the way the creators of this show imagine a world where survival has become the one and only priority.

How is Cole meant to save the human race when 93.6% of it has already been obliterated? Time travel, of course. In the well-constructed opening scene, Cole travels back to 2013, where he kidnaps a virologist named Cassandra Railly (Amanda Schull), and tries desperately to convince her that they need to find and kill a man named Leland Goines ASAP. As you might imagine, it’s a tough sell. Dodging gunfire, he tells Cassandra that he’ll meet her in two years, before disappearing into thin air. As you might imagine, those next two years are a bit odd for Cassandra as she questions her own sanity, but goes to meet Cole. Can the man who knows our future work together with a woman in our present day to stop our annihilation? And what role will a mentally ill math genius (Emily Hampshire) who draws monkeys on her wall play in the destruction or salvation?

The first two episodes of “12 Monkeys” hew relatively closely to the narrative of the film but diverge in crucial enough ways that one can start to see how this could work as a longer series. I’m still a bit unconvinced however that the writers of this show have enough fuel to keep the narrative spinning for multiple episodes or seasons, as it gets further and further away from the Marker and Gilliam source material. At what point does it become more like “Timecop” than Gilliam? I’m not convinced at all by the first two episodes that the writing here can be consistent or deep enough to overcome the B-movie clichés that are going to envelope this project once they’ve cribbed all they can from the Gilliam film. One can already see the clouds on the horizon.


The only reason for real hope and to keep watching is Railly. She makes a very convincing lead, reminding one of Amy Acker in her “Buffy/Angel” days. Acker had a remarkable ability to convey both deep intelligence and vulnerability—sadly, most female protagonists are smart OR in danger, not both—and Railly has that as well. She kept me engaged even when the first two episodes of “12 Monkeys” often worked against her. If the show is going to work long-term, one hopes that the rest of the production rises to her level.

Next Article: FOX’s “Backstrom” is Most Egregious Midseason MisfirePrevious Article: FXX’s “Man Seeking Woman” Needs to Find Better Match with Comic Timing

Reveal Commentscomments powered by

The "12 Monkeys" TV series has got at least one thing its big-screen counterpart didn't have: specially-programmed mood lighting. Syfy has partnered with Hue, Apple's LED home lighting system, to create a viewing atmosphere in which the light levels and colors fluctuate to complement whatever happens on-screen (they first experimented with this process for "Sharknado 2"). Pro-tip: give the neighbors a heads up, so they don't call the fire department when they see those red lights flashing through your windows.

We've discussed tarot card tie-ins in the site before, but that was before Eva Green wowed us with her cartomancy skills on "Penny Dreadful," Showtime's recent mash-up gothic masterpieces like Frankenstein and The Picture of Dorian Gray. Think Geek has licensed an official 78-card deck just like the one Green's character uses, and there's even a page that will generate a free reading for you electronically. (Mine said my soul-mate would reveal himself to be a monster, trampling on my heart and my greatest desires. If that sounds like you, gimme a call.)

Daniel Sayers' new book A Desolate Place for a Defiant People is a history of the Great Dismal Swamp in Virginia and North Carolina, which became a home centuries ago for runaway slaves who never managed to make it up North. Listen to the whole incredible story on NPR, an excellent prelude to the book and also an upcoming exhibition at the brand new Smithsonian museum dedicated to African-American History and Culture.

Unfortunately we need these reminders just as much as ever. In a recent essay, Chris Rock laid down a lot of incredibly passionate, intelligent observations about race relations in the comedy and motion picture worlds. Promoting his new film "Top Five," Rock writes of the importance of helping out younger performers who are unlikely to find a foothold in an industry where, for some reason, only a white person is qualified to decide "how loud the boings are in 'Dodgeball.'" Quoth he: "The odds are, because people are people, that there's probably a Mexican David Geffen mopping up for somebody's company right now." Here's hoping 2014 has been an eye-opening year for the people who run those companies.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *